6 Ways Credit Unions Can Make Social Media Drive Growth
By Nicole Volpe, Contributor at The Financial Brand
Simple Subscribe
Subscribe Now!
Social media is a hungry beast, and financial services marketers can be forgiven for focusing on feeding it. In many ways, the old Web 2.0 mantra that “every company is a media company” still holds true. But the focus on social media’s reach can too often neglect what is arguably its greatest strength: the interactivity that enables institutions to build familiarity, trust, and connection.
The lack of intentional focus when it comes to social media can lead to some strange role reversals. Large national banks might try to sound like community financial institutions, piling on local references and emphasizing values like financial wellness. And community institutions might (inadvertently) present themselves as soulless hyper-marketers as they pack their feeds with promo cards and try to emulate fintechs.
Too many credit unions have fallen into this trap. Their marketing teams maintain robust content calendars, with posts about new branch staff and community events intermingled with promotions for car loans and CD rates. But they don’t have a social media content problem; they have a social media strategy problem.
The situation is especially frustrating for credit unions, because they already have what social media rewards most — authentic community connections and a focus on affiliation and belonging. To understand how these institutions can turn social media back to their strategic advantage, The Financial Brand spoke to Christopher Coppola and Niki Corbett at evōk Advertising, a full-service marketing agency that specializes in digital strategy for credit unions.
Here are six strategic and tactical shifts credit unions can make to reset social media strategy and turn it into a driver of growth and long-term relationship value.
1. Start With Business Goals
The most common social media mistake credit unions make is building a strategy around content output rather than growth targets, e.g., loans, deposits, new memberships. Coppola, evōk’s Creative Director and VP, acknowledges some credit unions may feel that putting sales first runs counter to their non-profit, member-benefit mission.
But such an approach can, paradoxically, have the opposite effect, giving the institution a data-driven way to strike a better balance between promotion and engagement — a reason not to flood the zone with promo cards. This requires marketing and product teams to align, and together reverse-engineer a social strategy that targets results rather than managing to frequency targets and follower counts.
2. Know Your Audience
Credit unions often find themselves operating with internally conflicting points of view. “Different teams within the organization can sometimes have different ideas about who the member is, what the market looks like, and where growth opportunities exist,” said Corbett, Senior Account Executive at evōk. “It’s important to really dig into this, get to the truth and create alignment.”
This requires detailed audience analysis, including persona development. Effective personas go beyond demographics to capture financial pain points, content-consumption habits, and decision triggers. They help bring product and marketing onto the same page while giving social media teams the insight they need to target more accurately, design stronger content, and maintain consistency across member journeys.
Audience analysis also informs platform selection. TikTok, for example, may be the right place to reach younger consumers learning about first-time homebuying, while home-loan content for more-financially established personas may perform better on Instagram. Community events may belong on Facebook, where they will strengthen ties among older, primary accountholders.
3. Measure What Moves Members
Core engagement data matters but it’s essential to focus on metrics that link social activity to member behavior. “Social media changed from a distribution channel into a behavioral influence system a long time ago,” Coppola said. “And financial brands that aren’t treating it like this are falling behind.”
He advises institutions to track the full member journey from the first social touchpoint through website visit, inquiry, and application, and then to use that data to optimize existing approaches and design new ones.
A spike in abandoned loan applications should trigger a review of the social tactics that led to it. If a credit union’s social posts — regardless of their subject matter — all lead to its homepage or products and services page, drop-off rates are likely to spike.
4. Lean Into Your Local Advantage
Credit unions’ community roots give them a social media edge that digitally-savvy competitors like national banks and fintechs can’t replicate. “Social media gives them a chance to show who they are beyond rates and products,” said Corbett, Senior Account Executive at evōk. “It’s where they communicate personality, values, community involvement — and expertise, too — in a much more human way.”
Consider a credit union that deploys a mobile banking unit to an underserved area — and then documents and amplifies their work in that neighborhood via short videos and photos posted on its social platforms. Such community-focused posts, Corbett said, consistently outperform product and rate content in engagement terms.
Especially as credit unions expand into markets without a physical branch, these social posts become the proof points of community investment that builds trust and opens the door to member relationships.
5. Negative Feedback is an Opportunity
Some credit unions may instinctively pull back from social engagement because they fear it will invite public complaints and negative experiences. But maybe that’s a feature rather than a bug. Yes, consumer trust in financial institutions is fragile, especially among Gen Z; last year, the CFPB reported a 53% year-over-year increase in complaints about checking and savings accounts.
But such fragility can play in an institution’s favor when members and prospects see their credit union meet criticism with speed and transparency, approachability and empathy.
“Do not ignore or hide your public complaints — show them you are committed, that you matter to them,” Coppola said. “Respond and engage authentically.” Acknowledging the problem, communicating what’s being done and engaging directly with critical comments can produce a higher order of loyalty than a steady stream of upbeat, self-promotional content.
6. Break the Stigma Around Money
Financial education content is often seen as low-engagement and low-impact, often for good reason: Much of it feels generic — compliance-oriented and product-oriented — and disconnected from consumers’ day-to-day anxieties.
But when it is embedded naturally in the social feed rather than packaged as a series of formal assets, financial education can lower the emotional barriers that keep members from turning to the institution as their needs change. Coppola advises institutions to make themselves accessible and deliver educational content in constructive and focused ways — without judgment.
“Financial confidence grows when intimidation disappears,” Coppola said. “For both businesses and consumers, if there’s something affecting your community and your brand helps champion that cause, they see you as somebody that is in the struggle with them.” He cites the example of an institution that built a social education strategy around freedom from debt: the credit union’s own employees participated in the program and documented their journey publicly.
The Human Factor
The biggest misconception, Corbett said, is the idea that “social media is just marketing.” For community financial institutions, it can be something more powerful: a way to build relationships, understand the market, and stay relevant in accountholders’ everyday lives.
Credit unions are especially well positioned to take advantage. Their mission already rests on connection, trust, and shared values. A strong social strategy brings those qualities forward by humanizing the institution through authentic engagement. It starts with identifying the right audiences within the social graph, then speaking to them, as Corbett put it, “in the right place and the right voice, understanding their needs and offering to meet their needs, listening to them, making the brand feel human.”
In this way, social media can become strategic, a central pillar of marketing, not just driving traffic but supporting growth goals and creating long-term relationship value.
