The Interchange War: Why Card Revenue Has Become a Multi-Front Battle
By Tony DeSanctis, Cornerstone Advisors
Simple Subscribe
Subscribe Now!
Financial institutions have relied on interchange as a major driver of non-interest income for almost four decades. That reliance may be coming to an end.
Regulatory and competitive landscapes are creating significant headwinds for interchange income at a time when payments are more important than ever.
Why this matters: Card interchange represents $66 billion in annual revenue, which, for community financial institutions, averages between 25% and 30% of non-interest income, according to the Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis.
This revenue is under attack on multiple fronts, and banks must prepare for the coming onslaught.
Need to Know:
- Three forces are converging to put pressure on interchange income and the deposit relationships that support it:
- The regulatory/legal landscape continues to favor merchants. Real impacts are just beginning to be felt by issuing institutions.
- Fintech disruption in the market is taking primary banking relationships and transactions from core deposit accounts.
- The alternative payments landscape represents real risk not only to payments revenue but to core deposits.
Key Factors Impacting the Regulatory/Legal Landscape
Two major potential changes on the regulatory horizon stem from, first, a North Dakota lawsuit targeting regulated financial institutions with assets over $10 billion in assets, and, second, the credit card settlement being finalized retailers and Visa and Mastercard.
• The North Dakota lawsuit affects regulated institutions and the way the interchange cap is calculated. The courts have said that only variable costs associated with the transaction should be considered in the debit cap, so any fixed costs would need to be removed. Any costs not directly tied to the transaction processing (statements, plastics and some fixed fraud costs) would also have to be excluded from the calculation.
Key risk: The appeals court ruled in line with the original court on this definition. While a couple of avenues of appeal remain, including the Supreme Court, it is increasingly likely that this could become the new requirement for regulated interchange.
• The Visa/Mastercard Credit Card Settlement is nearing completion, with multiple impacts on credit card interchange. These include card acceptance, the standard card interchange cap, and a 10 basis point reduction in rewards interchange for the next five years. This will likely take effect in 2027, so institutions should adjust their budgets accordingly.
Technically merchants will be able to reject Visa Signature, Mastercard World Elite, or other premium cards, it is highly improbable that merchants will block a sale from a customer who only has premium cards in their wallet. Not to mention, the alternative card a customer would probably reach for is an American Express card, which is generally more expensive for the merchant.
What this means: The standard card interchange will be capped at 125 bps for the next eight years, which, depending on an institution’s card product and mix, could be a 20 to 30 bps decrease in its standard credit card interchange. Depending on the size of the institution’s standard card portfolio, it will need to adjust its go-forward interchange forecast for the next eight years or look at potential product upgrades.
The reduction in rewards interchange will be more of a slow bleed, at 10 bps per year over the next five years; by the end, it would represent a 20% to 30% reduction in rewards interchange.
The real question for financial institutions will be: Do you reduce the value of rewards to offset this loss? Or reduce your margin on your rewards products?
Read more: Why Credit Card Surcharges Are Costing Banks Transaction Flow
Fintech Disruption on Card Interchange
The top six fintechs in the United States (Affirm, Klarna, SoFi, Chime, PayPal and Cash App) currently represent over 60 million debit cards, or roughly 8% of the market.
Key insight: While this is troubling enough, recent research by Ron Shevlin at Cornerstone Advisors revealed that 53% of consumers opening new accounts are doing so with a fintech neobank. This was before Revolut even moved into this market.
The concern here is not only the interchange implications but the deposit disruption of these fintechs becoming primary financial institutions. For example, Cash App no longer discloses total debit cards but rather reports the number of primary accounts it holds as 9.4 million as of last quarter’s earnings.
Read more: Three Ways to Jumpstart Troubled Borrowers’ Debt Repayment Efforts
Alternative Payments Stream Also Erode Interchange Income
Stablecoins, pay by bank, faster payments, buy now, pay later (BNPL) — these disruptive payment solutions are all impacting interchange. While faster payments and stablecoins are more likely to disrupt commercial and cross-border payments, respectively, they also have the potential to disrupt traditional commercial credit card interchange.
The biggest risks to interchange from a consumer perspective are pay by bank and, to a lesser extent, BNPL.
• Pay by bank connects a consumer’s checking account directly to a financial institution’s online banking solution via Plaid or another platform. This completely bypasses the card rails and eliminates all of the institution’s interchange on those transactions.
This has a bigger impact on credit than debit in terms of total interchange, but it also impacts the loan portion of the credit card, which is the generator of most credit profitability.
• BNPL similarly impacts credit card interchange. While the financial institution does receive interchange on BNPL payments made with a debit card, it misses the credit card interchange and the potential loan balances that would be driven if a credit card is used rather than a BNPL solution.
Read next: Why Card-Based BNPL Is Poised to Become the Mainstream Pay-Later Channel
Action Steps Issuers Can Take
How can banks address these interchange impacts?
• Size the potential impact of the interchange legal and regulatory changes and plan accordingly. When prices go down, you have to make it up on volume. Investing in marketing and promoting card usage is the best way to offset the loss of interchange here.
• Assess fintech’s erosion of your business. Fintech disruptors are winning new consumer accounts at an alarming rate, so evaluating your value proposition and your marketing strategies are key to winning back these new accounts. Much of your spend growth and, by default, interchange, is driven by the growth of new accounts and the incremental spend they bring to your card portfolio.
• Pick a strategy to deal with payment rail jumping. Disruptive payment options mean you will have to identify those likely to impact customers directly, especially pay by bank and BNPL, and determine how to either adopt or compete with these offerings.
The Bottom Line
Interchange is being disrupted on many fronts and will probably decrease on a per-transaction basis over the coming years. That being said, continued growth in spending and new accounts will be the key to growth not only for the institution’s overall interchange but also its long-term core deposits.
Read next: How Should Banks Weigh Opportunities in Payment Stablecoins as License Deadline Nears?
