Skip to main content

“Be Curious”: Why Member Success Is Your Missing Revenue Strategy

By Sean O'Neill, Head of Growth at FMSI

Published on November 18th, 2026 in Innovation Strategies

Simple Subscribe

Subscribe Now!

Stay on top of all the latest news and trends in the banking industry.

Consent Granted*

A member stops in on a busy afternoon to deposit a check. While the teller’s working on it, she mentions her daughter just got into college. The teller congratulates her, wraps up the deposit, and calls the next person, since there are four of them waiting. Nobody asks how the family plans to pay for school.

The teller did their job. The branch just didn’t leave any space for the conversation that should have come next, so that member walked out with a need nobody asked about.

Reality check: That kind of miss costs more than it used to. J.D. Power’s 2026 U.S. Retail Banking Satisfaction Study found the average checking customer now keeps deposit accounts at three different institutions, and 20% moved money out of their primary bank in the prior three months, up from 17% a year earlier. J.D. Power calls it “soft switching,” and lists falling satisfaction with personal service among the warning signs. Nobody closes an account over one missed question about tuition. Enough of those moments, though, and members start opening accounts somewhere else.

For 16 years, I’ve worked in jobs where taking care of customers and growing the business were one job, first in retail, then enterprise tech and now banking. I truly believe member success is one of the best revenue engines a credit union or community bank has, and that the same work that grows revenue makes members happier.

It Started at Starbucks

I picked up most of this running a Starbucks. For almost seven years I worked in and managed the second-busiest store in the Southeast. Seeing roughly 1,200 transactions a day, we took annual revenue from $3 million to $4.5 million.

Most people came in for one thing and planned to leave with one thing. If you asked a decent question, or you saw a repeat customer enough mornings to know what they usually liked, they’d often add something. Do that across a day like ours, and it shows up in the numbers.

Key insight: The day-to-day looked a lot like branch management. I spent a lot of my time on how the line moved, who was scheduled when, and whether we had the right people on for the morning rush. If we were covered, my team could talk to people. If we weren’t, we were just trying to get drinks out, and no extra conversations were had.

Founder, Sales, Client Success

After Starbucks, I started a company from scratch. Running your own business makes the link between service and revenue hard to miss, because an unhappy customer shows up in your bank account pretty fast.

From there, I went into sales and account management in enterprise tech, with clients that included Google, Rolls-Royce, and Pinterest. We chased new business as everyone does, but the growth I could count on year after year came from existing clients who trusted us.

Most recently, I ran client success, which got me thinking a lot more about the overall process. Every team has a couple of people customers love. I wanted a team where good service didn’t depend on who happened to be working that day, and I’ve carried that same goal into banking. Credit unions and community banks have a head start on it, because their members still walk in the door.

Four Things I Believe

My whole approach really boils down to “be curious,” and most of the rest is about making room for it. Give people time, and they’ll get curious about members. The curiosity builds trust, and the trust gets you the next conversation.

1. Be curious. A curious banker asks why the member came in, what’s changed for them, and what they might need next. Loans, new accounts, and long relationships come out of those questions, and members feel heard and valued as staff shows a vested interest in what they need.

Key insight: There’s research on this too. A study cited by PYMNTS in its Credit Union Tracker with Velera found 76% of Gen Z consumers say they’ll act on personalized guidance from an in-branch conversation. Just about every good opportunity I’ve been part of started with somebody asking a question they didn’t have to ask, yet most frontline staff simply don’t have time to ask it.

2. Give people the time. Most institutions already employ people who’d be great at these conversations. They spend their days on walk-ins nobody planned for, covering shifts and rushing handoffs. Getting them out of that is an operations job, with clear processes and tools that calm the day down. When it’s done well, member satisfaction and revenue tend to rise together.

3. Earn the trust. People buy from people they find credible. To me, that means owning the outcome for the member in front of you, being prepared, following through, and showing up the same way every time. Since trust gets earned in service and makes the next conversation possible, I’ve always treated client success as a revenue function.

4. Make it a mindset. Plenty of leaders run client success like a support desk that cleans up problems. In a branch, it’s the face of the business and the biggest driver of satisfaction and growth. Giving someone a client success title won’t make it happen. The whole team has to adopt it, put it into practice, and keep at it.

-- Article continued below --

Making the Time: A Holistic Look at Branch Health

Essentially, if you want your team to be curious and get to know members better, you have to put systems and processes in place that let them do it, right? Asking people to be curious while their whole day is reactive won’t get you very far.

This is getting more important as branch visits change. In Santander US’s Q2 2026 survey of middle-income Americans, 89% said they want to handle most banking digitally but still have a branch with people who can help when needed. Credit unions are responding. Wipfli research cited in the same PYMNTS tracker found that, among credit union executives planning to repurpose branches, 76% intend to turn them into advisory hubs. A new layout won’t free up anyone’s calendar, though. How the branch runs day to day decides that.

Here’s where I’d focus:

  1. Know who’s coming in and why. A banker who learns what the member needs after they sit down has nothing prepared. With appointment scheduling, staff can see the day’s visits and what each one is about, so members sit down with someone who’s already up to speed. Booking also tends to catch on once members try it. One credit union’s data, published here earlier this year, showed scheduled visits rising from a little over half of its branch traffic in 2020 to 86% in 2025.
  2. Get the lobby under control. Walk-in rushes and unpredictable waits pull staff into reactive mode faster than anything. Lobby management smooths out the flow, so members wait less and have a better sense of how long they’ll be there, and staff can give longer conversations the time they need.
  3. Match the schedule to the conversations. Plenty of branches have enough bodies on the floor at the busiest hour but not the right mix, say three people who can handle transactions and nobody who can talk through a loan. Staff scheduling that accounts for both demand and the kinds of visits members are booking helps put the right person there.
  4. Watch the numbers. Leaders need to see traffic, outcomes, and opportunities branch by branch. Without that, every location runs on its own habits and members get a different experience depending on which door they use.

These work best together. Scheduling without lobby management, or staffing without the data behind it, only solves part of the problem. Put all four in place and a branch can plan the day ahead of time, which is what gives people room to have better conversations.

I’ve started calling this “branch health”. A healthy branch:

  • Holds on to its employees, who get to spend more of their day on meaningful work.
  • Opens up more opportunities for members, since staff has the time and context to ask better questions.
  • Spends fewer expensive admin hours building schedules and chasing coverage.
  • Becomes the first place members think of for anything financial.

Right now, my focus is helping credit unions and community banks get these pieces working, so the right person is in the branch when a member shows up with something to talk about.

Member Success Is the Growth Strategy

Plenty of institutions still file member service under expenses and go looking for growth elsewhere. I think a lot of it is already sitting in the lobby.

If you run a credit union or community bank, try asking a few questions about your own branches:

  • How much of your frontline team’s day is reactive, and how much is planned?
  • Do your bankers know who’s coming in tomorrow, and why?
  • At your busiest hour, is the person on the floor the one your members need?
  • When a member mentions something big in passing, does anyone have time to follow up?

If you don’t love the answers, you’re in good company. It usually means your people don’t have room to be curious yet. Get the operations sorted out, and satisfaction and revenue tend to come along together. If member success matters to you, give your people the time to work on it.

-- Article continued below --

About the Author

Sean O'Neill is Head of Growth at FMSI, which provides branch performance and workforce management solutions to banks and credit unions. His 16-year career has paired customer experience with account growth, beginning as a Starbucks store manager.