The First 90 Days Decide Whether Your Card Ever Becomes Top-of-Wallet
By Liz Froment, Contributor at The Financial Brand
Simple Subscribe
Subscribe Now!
When your customer’s credit card is approved, it’s tempting to count the job as done. But for a community bank or credit union, the race is only just getting started.
The ideal path starts at approval and then moves from activation to the card being top-of-wallet. An activated card that just sits in a drawer may never earn back the costs of acquiring the customer in the first place. Premium cards from the biggest issuers can offer introductory rewards that require investments close to $1,000, but even a standard card may cost as much as $250 to acquire new customers. If members don’t use the card frequently, banks may need to wait up to three years to see positive revenue.
That’s why the first 90 days after approval are so critical. In this time frame, a customer may decide whether the card is the first they reach for, or it’s forgotten.
Need to Know:
- Approval is the first step. A new card can cost up to $250 to acquire and take up to three years to turn profitable if members don’t use it.
- Faster first use matters. Prompting digital wallet setup early helps members start using the card sooner.
- Welcome offers don’t always build habits. Sign-up bonuses are a top reason cardholders give for getting cards that are now inactive.
- Outreach should follow behavior. Messages tied to what the cardmembers are doing, coordinated across campaigns, work better than relying on a fixed outreach calendar.
- Warning signs show up early. Slow first purchases or longer gaps between purchases may be a red flag that the card is heading for a drawer.
Closing the Gap Between Approval and First Use
The primary hurdle institutions face is getting the card used in the first place. “The experience immediately after approval is really important. You’re trying to make it as easy as possible for someone to actually start using the card,” Nola Ogunyemi, SVP of consumer lending at BECU, told The Financial Brand.
Key insight: Letting card members add the card to a digital wallet right away, rather than waiting for the physical version to arrive, removes obstacles to their first purchase, says Ogunyemi.
“The longer you make someone wait, the more opportunity there is for that excitement and intent to fade.”
Kevin Smith, president of Mighty Roar, a digital marketing agency that works with credit unions, recommends prompting digital wallet enrollment as soon as the technology allows. Ideally, that happens while members are setting up the app, with a direct “add to wallet” button.
But not every credit union leads with the wallet. “We introduce digital wallets fairly early in onboarding, but we don’t make it the first thing we communicate. Our digital wallet and card controls message goes out after the initial welcome and an introduction to the card’s rewards and benefits,” Megan Smith, vice president of marketing and communications for Trumark Credit Union, told The Financial Brand.
Trumark also helps members who prefer to pick up their cards in person. “Our Member Service Representatives assist with adding the card to their mobile wallet before they leave the branch, making it easy for them to start using it immediately,” Megan Smith says.
Key insight: For Kevin Smith, enrollment is one milestone, not the primary goal for institutions. “Give the cardmember a clear reason to use the card for a purchase they already make, whether that’s groceries, gas, or another regular expense that fits the card’s benefits,” he says.
Moving Beyond the Welcome Offer
According to the Auriemma Group, about 33% of credit cardholders have at least one card they haven’t used in the last six months. In 2025, 30% of cardholders cited sign-up bonuses as the top reason why they got the cards that are now inactive, up from 22% in 2023.
“An introductory offer can absolutely give someone a reason to make that first purchase, but you don’t want to have to keep paying someone to use your card. After that initial transaction, the value needs to be relevant to how they already spend,” says Ogunyemi. “The best long-term strategy isn’t necessarily the richest promotion. It’s creating enough everyday value that using the card becomes an easy choice.”
For Trumark and Megan Smith, that means showing members “the ongoing benefits of having the card.” She explains how they approach tailored follow-up messages by card type:
- Cash back: Show them how to earn cash back in different spending categories and how to redeem it.
- Rewards card: Explain how to earn rewards faster and the different ways they can redeem their points.
- Lower-rate card: Highlight the benefit of a lower interest rate and introduce options like balance transfers.
Trumark also has a messaging strategy around reward redemptions. After an eligible purchase, members are asked via text or email whether they want to apply their points; if they confirm, the points apply automatically. “Ultimately, it’s about making sure members understand everything their card has to offer and giving them reasons to continue using it beyond the initial welcome offer,” says Megan Smith.
Key insight: Kevin Smith recommends testing which incentives drive repeat use and purchases, then measuring what happens after the offer ends to see whether behavior changes.
“If usage falls away as soon as the reward does, I wouldn’t call that a habit yet. Incentives should help cardmembers experience the card’s ongoing value. Otherwise, the institution risks paying repeatedly for the same behavior without building a stronger preference,” Kevin Smith says.
Acting on Customer Behavior
“The best outreach isn’t necessarily based on a calendar, it’s based on what the cardmember is doing,” says Ogunyemi.
Trumark builds a 90-day early-month-on-book strategy around that idea, using separate communication lanes for members who have activated their cards and those who haven’t. Good onboarding communications strategies can positively impact credit card use. Data from ampliFI found that users who received structured rewards onboarding for cards saw a 32.4% lift in use in the first 90 days and 30.2% higher spend after 12 months than control groups.
Effective communication also means understanding what messages your customers receive from your institution and avoiding the wrong ones. “An activation reminder sent after someone has activated makes the institution look less aware of the relationship it’s trying to build,” says Kevin Smith. He also recommends coordinating onboarding with the overall marketing strategy, since new cardmembers may receive promotional offers, onboarding messages, and other communications from the bank at the same time. “You need to consider that entire experience, not just the messages coming from one campaign.”
Coordination works best when it’s guided by cardmember behavior. Sending the right message at the right time means spotting potentially negative behavioral signals before the card goes dormant.
Key insight: “Don’t wait until someone stops using the card completely to decide they’re disengaged. There are usually signals before that happens,” says Ogunyemi.
There are several warning signs that Ogunyemi, Megan Smith, and Kevin Smith all watch for, including:
- No first purchase within the first 30 days of activation
- A longer gap between purchases, especially the first and second
- A lot of early spending that stops once the welcome offer is met
- Spending frequency that starts dropping during the second or third month
- No rewards activity or redemption
- Limited engagement with the institution
When those signals start appearing, institutions should have a targeted follow-up strategy in place to help re-engage. That might include offering technical support or reminding the member of the benefits they can get from using the card.
“We don’t want to wait until a card becomes inactive to try to re-engage someone,” says Megan Smith.
Bottom Line: Make the First 90 Days Count
Cards often end up in drawers during the first 90 days when the path to the first purchase is slow, members aren’t given opportunities to build habits around using the card, and warning signs are ignored. Credit unions and community banks that make it easy to use and give members a reason to keep coming back have the best chance of becoming the card members reach for first.
