Skip to main content

How Your Onboarding May be Misaligned with Today’s Customers

By Ben Udell at Ben Udell Consulting

Published on November 11th, 2026 in Onboarding

Simple Subscribe

Subscribe Now!

Stay on top of all the latest news and trends in the banking industry.

Consent Granted*

Many financial institutions (FIs), if they have an onboarding program, focus on new checking relationships, with an emphasis on securing the direct deposit, getting online and mobile tools set up, and ensuring the account is actively used. And, indeed, strong onboarding is one of the most influential drivers of long-term relationship growth and profitability.

Reality check: But not all onboarding is created equal. Banks and credit unions need to understand the different financial needs and products that drive new relationship growth, which will then allow them to more effectively tailor an onboarding program to win more business and build loyalty.

If you approach onboarding strictly through the lens of a new checking account, you’re missing out on distinctly different relationship journeys:

  • An indirect auto borrower may not even recognize your institution’s name, you were simply the best rate at the dealership.
  • A mortgage borrower may be focused solely on the home purchase, and they’re working with you because of their realtor’s relationship with your mortgage officer.
  • A new high yield savings account was opened online because you had the best rate in town.
  • An investment relationship may have begun with a 401k rollover.

None of these scenarios signal a desire to open a checking account, or to engage more deeply with your products and services. These customers have little reason to disrupt their current payment connections, spending habits, or direct deposit.

Result: These non-checking relationships are on borrowed time. When the loan is paid off, the relationship is done. When rates change, they’ll move their deposit elsewhere.

Key insight : A one size fits all approach to onboarding doesn’t work. Understanding the customer’s goals and motivations for change, and learning how to market to these relationships, requires a different approach.

Cadence, Content, and Channel: The Framework for Modern Onboarding

Once we acknowledge that onboarding must adapt to the way a relationship actually begins, the question becomes: How do we design an onboarding experience that reflects those differences while driving meaningful engagement? The answer lies in reframing onboarding decisions around three critical pillars: cadence, content, and channel.

These three elements work together to shape how a new customer or member experiences your FI from day one. And because each entry point reflects a different motivation and level of awareness, these pillars must adapt accordingly.

  1. Cadence defines the rhythm of communication. Checking relationships may benefit from a more concentrated early sequence because they’ve already signaled intent and have action steps needed to establish how they use the new account. Whereas indirect auto or mortgage relationships simply need to make their payments on time. This insight drives the pace and timing of your communication.
  2. Content is the value you deliver with each message. Product pushes for sales alone won’t create a primary relationship. These new relationships, especially for indirect auto loans, literally might be unable to remember your institution’s name. Building brand awareness with quality content opens the door for future sales and a deeper relationship.
  3. Channel ensures you’re communicating in the right places: email, text, direct mail, branch employees, and website interactions. Not every channel will make sense for every relationship, but every new relationship deserves a thoughtful strategy to maximize its long-term potential.

Together, cadence, content, and channel form the strategic foundation for onboarding success. They ensure that the way you communicate is aligned with why and how the customer or member started a relationship in the first place. This framework sets the stage for exploring each pillar more deeply, and ultimately for designing onboarding journeys that convert transactional beginnings into long-term, profitable, and loyal relationships.

Cadence: Designing the Right Rhythm for Every Relationship

In checking onboarding, a tight cadence makes sense, because new customers or members have already demonstrated intent. They’re motivated to establish the relationship, complete setup tasks, and begin using the account. The first 90 to 180 days of the relationship set the foundation for potentially a decade long relationship. Frequent communication helps reinforce their decision and guide the behaviors that lead to PFI status.

But this same cadence applied to non-checking relationships misses the mark entirely. Non-checking relationships did not start a relationship with your FI because they were dissatisfied with another FI. Your rate, product, or timing made the decision for them. You may have literally been in the right place at the right time.

Banks and credit unions need to remember what drives PFI change: customer service, fees, or life events. Your marketing can’t be timed to these events. A more effective cadence for non-checking onboarding is:

  • Longer-term, extending across the life of the product. The customer or member might be willing to switch in year three of their auto loan, when their current PFI makes a mistake.
  • Light yet consistent, so your brand remains present without overwhelming. You’re building brand awareness and credibility so you’re first in line when it’s time to switch.
  • Evergreen, focused on education, financial wellness, and brand awareness rather than immediate product push. These customers or members are not looking to buy, which means a sales message isn’t received as well as a financial literacy message.

Key insight : This longer runway recognizes a simple truth: These relationships will consider new products when life or financial needs change, not because they received a checking account offer. When that moment comes, your FI must be first in line. Cadence becomes your tool to earn that position.

Cadence must be more consistent than traditionally thought. A weekly touchpoint is not unreasonable, especially when spread thoughtfully across multiple channels with engaging content. You’re not selling, you’re educating, and your customers or members know the difference.

An engaging rhythm over multiple channels works because:

  • Consumers dip in and out of communication streams, you must be present when they are paying attention.
  • Multi-channel distribution reduces fatigue, since messages reach the consumer in different formats, at different times, and for different purposes.
  • Value-forward content builds trust, giving you “permission” to show up more often.
  • Long-term nurturing requires consistency, especially for relationships that did not join you with intent to deepen the relationship.

An effective cadence is about being reliably present and on brand. Remember, the trigger to change checking account providers is often random and chaotic. The goal is to create a rhythm where your brand becomes familiar, your value becomes recognized, and your presence becomes welcomed and expected.

Content: Delivering Value That Builds Awareness, Trust, and Future Intent

If cadence determines when you communicate, content determines why the customer or member should care. And for non-checking onboarding, this distinction is critical.

Traditional checking onboarding relies on action-oriented content: set up direct deposit, activate your debit card, enroll in digital banking. This works because the customer or member has already decided you’re their new financial home. The purpose of the content is to reinforce momentum and remove friction.

Key insight : Non-checking relationships have different needs in the first 90 days. Content is the bridge between transactional entry point and relationship potential. It’s how you move from being the institution that financed their car or mortgage to being the institution they trust with their broader financial life.

Importantly, quality content gives you permission to maintain a longer cadence. It ensures your presence is valued and not intrusive. It transforms every message into a touchpoint that builds familiarity, credibility, and long-term intent.

Reality check: Many FIs struggle with creating content. The key is to understand that a lot of content has already been created and can be repurposed. For instance, community events, donations, and content discussing senior leaders can easily be updated and added to your onboarding campaign. You’re likely sharing fraud alerts and insights, and these can easily be repurposed. Your website has blogs and financial literacy that can be shared. This is evergreen content that only requires an upfront time commitment to build before it becomes repeatable.

Content Ideas to Kickstart Your Onboarding Efforts

Brand Awareness & Institutional Identity: Many indirect auto, mortgage, or investment customers don’t know who you are. Early content should introduce your FI, highlight your mission, share community involvement, and spotlight key digital tools or service resources. These messages establish familiarity and help position your FI as more than a loan statement while expanding the relationship beyond a mortgage or investment officer.

Product-Specific Education: Customers and members value knowledge that helps them manage the product they already have. For indirect auto, this could include understanding loan terms, protect vehicle value, or learning how payment history impacts credit. Mortgage content may focus on home maintenance, escrow education, or refinancing basics, while investment relationships may appreciate guidance on retirement planning or market fundamentals. This type of content meets them where they are today and builds trust.

Financial Wellness & Literacy: Evergreen, value-driven content is ideal for sustaining a longer cadence. Topics such as credit score improvement, budgeting strategies, fraud prevention, and building savings habits keep your institution relevant and helpful throughout the year, enhancing your position as a trusted financial partner. Customers and members look to their financial providers to help them better manage their financial picture. Positioning your FI well moves you to the top of options when it’s time to switch checking accounts.

Digital Banking & Convenience Tools: Many non-checking relationships don’t know about the convenience tools your FI offers. The relationships opening process is not often conducive to these discussions, creating a gap in awareness. Content showcasing mobile banking features, alerts, bill pay, P2P payments, fraud controls, and account aggregation introduces them to capabilities that can quietly influence long-term relationship decisions and future product consideration.

Relevant Cross-Sell Introductions: Once awareness and trust have been established, you can begin weaving in product relevance. Indirect auto borrowers may respond well to low-rate credit card content or reminders about the next auto purchase cycle. Mortgage customers or members may be receptive to HELOC education, high yield savings accounts to other rate focused products, while investment relationships may benefit from savings or deposit product introductions. These should appear only after establishing value-based communication. A true relationship lessens the dependence on converting sales based on high priced offers or rates and limits customers’ or members’ need to shop competitors.

Annual or Seasonal Value Builders: These touchpoints help maintain relevance over long periods without overwhelming the customer or member. Examples include year-end financial checklists, annual credit score insights, seasonal fraud alerts, and timely guides aligned with a natural cadence of the calendar. These messages help extend cadence in meaningful ways.

Strong content is the strategic backbone of non-checking onboarding. Over time, these touchpoints build recognition, credibility, and trust leading to greater loyalty and profitability.

Channel: Expanding Your Reach Through Intentional, Omni-Channel Communication

If cadence defines the rhythm and content defines the value, channel determines accessibility, your ability to ensure customers or members see and absorb what you send. And for non-checking onboarding, this becomes especially important. These relationships did not choose your FI because of a compelling brand promise or relationship advantage. They’re not looking for reasons to hear from you. That means relying on a single channel, like email, simply isn’t enough.

FIs must diversify channels to increase the odds of engagement. A well-constructed onboarding program for non-checking relationships should blend email, text messaging (where appropriate), direct mail, and digital interactions. Then you can connect banker outreach to reinforce the value of the relationship. Each channel offers different opportunities:

  • Email provides educational depth and supports consistent cadence.
  • Text messages deliver timely, high-visibility reminders or short updates.
  • Direct mail creates a tangible presence that stands out in a digital-heavy world and reinforces legitimacy.
  • Digital interactions through online/mobile tools, website retargeting, and other channels help connect to your customer or members’ digital lives.
  • Personal outreach, the time-tested focus on personal relationships, can unlock greater engagement in an increasingly digital world.

Key insight: A multi-channel approach also helps maintain the more engaging cadence required for these relationships. When messages are spread across different mediums, the communication load feels natural rather than overwhelming. A customer or member may ignore an email but respond to a text. They may miss a text but remember a direct mail piece. They may overlook a generic message but engage with a timely one that aligns with something they just did online.

A strong channel strategy does what cadence and content alone cannot achieve: it ensures your voice is heard in a world where attention is scarce and competition is constant.

Bringing It All Together: Redefining Onboarding for Modern Financial Relationships

Onboarding has always been essential to long-term relationship growth, but the industry has treated it as if all entry points are equal. The goal is to earn primary financial institution status, but this status cannot be forced. It develops over time through familiarity, value, trust, and positive experiences. For non-checking relationships it’s a multi-year strategy designed to keep your FI present and relevant until the customer or member is ready for change.

Bottom line: When developed to work together, cadence, content, and channel turn low-intent entry points into long-term relationship opportunities. They help ensure that when a life event occurs, when frustration with another bank or credit union surfaces, or when a customer or member is finally ready to make a financial change, your institution is the first name that comes to mind.

-- Article continued below --