The Financial Brand studied every name change in the U.S. credit union industry since 2006. There have been 234 credit union name changes in the last seven years. That represents 3.27% of all credit unions, but they collectively hold 5.52% of all credit union assets. Who’s changed names, and what are the current trends in credit union naming? Find out here.
Credit Union Name Changes in 2012
2012 saw the fewest name changes in the credit union industry in the last seven years — three fewer than in 2006. The pace of credit union name changes in clearly slowing. The average asset size for credit unions changing names last year was $123 million. The median is around $58 million. Notable new names rolled out in 2012 include GO, Solarity, Latitude 32, Evolve, Alive, Edge, CarePoint, ClearChoice, Fieldstone and BluCurrent.
|Old Name||New Name||Asset
|Albany Federal Employees||Members United||$55|
|Charleston Area||Latitude 32||$52|
|Eagle Legacy||Partner Colorado||$227|
|El Paso Employees||Evolve||$354|
|Equitable Resources Employees||EQT||$47|
|Florida Commerce||First Commerce||$363|
|Jersey Trades||Union Building Trades||$75|
|Liverpool Central School||Edge||$38|
|Postal Federal Community||BluCurrent||$138|
|Sangamon Schools||Illinois Educators||$48|
|St. John’s of Little Canada||Minnesota Catholic||$26|
|Tulsa Postal & Community||FirstOklahoma||$26|
|Waterbury Firefighters||FD Community||$61|
Naming Trends in the Credit Union Industry: First, Financial
There isn’t much value in using the word “First” in a financial institution’s name. The term is so ubiquitous in banking monikers it’s completely lost any meaning or cachet. Because so many banks and credit unions are already using “First” in their names, it makes it nearly impossible to secure a federally-protected trademark. Nevertheless, that didn’t stop 21 of the 234 credit unions (9.0%) with new names in the last seven years from embedding the word “First” somewhere in it. Two credit unions went with “Community First,” while another pair both went with “First Financial.”
Indeed some 16 different credit unions (6.8%) tacked the word “Financial” at the end of their name. The Financial Brand has previously noted a trend among credit unions who feel the “Financial” surname suits them better than “Credit Union.” XYZ Financial, the argument goes, is easier to for consumers to understand than XYZ Credit Union. The beauty of this approach is that you can take a rather ordinary word and make it seem financial simply by slipping the word “Financial” after it. Examples include Prime Financial, Partners Financial, Grow Financial and Power Financial.
Some 56 credit unions (23.9%) chose coined words as their new names. Critics of this type of name hate them because they look weird and often lack a clear connection or relevance to the brand. But it is because of their unique construction and unusual context that they are so easily trademarked. Anyone who’s worked in naming has heard the expression, “All the good names are taken.” While not necessarily true, the exaggeration illustrates the challenges and frustrations namers in the financial industry face. Being able to trademark your new brand and protect your investment is tantamount to all other concerns. It’s much more important to have an odd name you can own than a logical name you have to share with others.
Some of the more notable new coined names to come from the credit union industry since 2006 include: Altier, Inova, Viriva, Ascentra, Interra, Riverset, Altana, Aventa, Solarity, Abri, Everence, Astera and Envista. You’ll notice coined names commonly end in a soft “a” sound, giving them a quality some associate with pharmaceutical brands.
There have been several coined names in the last seven years that have sparked furious debate — NuUnion, Red Canoe, BluCurrent and Salal among them. One name change, Optiva, was so controversial it sparked petitions, legal filings, regulator rulings and two members votes. It was ultimately rejected. It was an ugly story.
Alphanumeric constructions are rare in the financial industry, but names like Plus4, Med 5, Coast360 and Latitude 32 are among the most unique you’ll ever see. Two credit unions went with just numbers: 121 and 360.
For many generations, financial institutions have aligned their names with the geographic area they served. It’s a formula that seems to have worked out okay, so many credit unions just stick with it. A total of 48 credit unions that have changed names since 2006 (20.5%) have included a geographic reference or emphasis in their new name. To a credit union that’s growing and just expanded its charter, its hard to imagine a time when they’d ever serve more than just City X or County Y. But that day could come. In fact, it could be only one quick merger away. And then what? You have to change names again. That’s always the main risk with geographic names.
One in five credit unions changing names adopts a common, regular word as its name. Some include predictable choices for the financial industry, like Security and Trust. Others like Argent are more clever. Verbs can be used to create a fresh financial context: Go, Grow, Magnify, Aspire, Amplify, Elevations. Other notable new names drawn from everyday words include Max, Via, Icon, Smart, Edge and Fieldstone.
Usually when a credit union picks an everyday word as its new name, members don’t usually make too much of a fuss. Some folks may scratch their head a little, but the volume of chatter is typically kept to a minimum. That wasn’t the case when one credit union picked Wildfire, perhaps the most controversial everyday word ever picked as a new name in the industry’s entire history.
Smaller and Smaller Credit Unions Are Changing Names
In 2006, 79% of all credit unions changing names had assets over $100 million, but by 2012 that percentage had dropped to only 33%. The other 67% all had assets under $100 million. Only one credit union with over $1 billion in assets has changed names in the last three years, and that wasn’t even really a name change (Addison Avenue adopted the name of its merger partner First Tech).
The total assets for all credit unions changing names in 2012 amounted to only $2 billion, the lowest amount in the last seven years. The average has been around $7 billion in combined assets.
Clearly the size of credit unions changing names is shrinking, and the pace of name changes is slowing.
|# Who Have
|2006||29||$316 million||$190 million|
|2007||34||$339 million||$153 million|
|2008||36||$281 million||$146 million|
|2009||42||$183 million||$92 million|
|2010||27||$151 million||$82 million|
|2011||42||$253 million||$85 million|
|2012||24||$123 million||$61 million|
All content © 2013 by The Financial Brand and may not be reproduced by any means without permission.