Pavlov’s Bankers

An article in American Banker about the JP Morgan Chase/WaMu deal quoted one consultant as saying:

“JPMorgan must be salivating at the opportunity to cross-sell products to Wamu’s customers to really deepen the relationships.”

My take: The consultant may be right about his assessment of JPMC’s reaction to the deal — and if he is, then the firm is seriously deluding itself. On the other hand, my bet is that the folks at JPMC are hardly describing their reaction in term of salivating.

First of all, the reality is that JPMC has been selling to WaMu customers for years. Every large financial institution spends a good deal of money building and using prospect databases to drive their acquisition marketing activities.

How will JPMC’s offers change as a result of having access to WaMu’s customer databases? In the short-term, nothing. And in the medium term, maybe nothing. The scope, scale, and cost of integrating the firms’ customer databases is huge, and will take years to accomplish.

Second, the “cross-sell opportunity” is the Pavlovian reaction that every acquiring bank has given when describing its rationale for merging with another institution. But take a moment to think about the deals that have occurred and which ones have delivered on this cross-sell promise.

Done thinking? How many did you come up with? None? What a coincidence! That’s how many I came up with.

Third, the current situation will actually exacerbate JPMC’s — and other large banks’ — ability to consolidate accounts.

One of the most prevalent reasons why consumers don’t consolidate accounts, and do business with just one bank, is that they “don’t want all their eggs in one basket.” I’ve wondered whether this sentiment will be prevalent among Gen Yers, and if the feeling would change among older consumers. The current financial crisis convinces me that the “eggs in one basket” reason for not consolidating will become even more prevalent over the next few years.

Given the failures of some this country’s largest banks, few consumers can really feel comfortable that any one bank — regardless of whether or not it has “too big to fail” status — is a good place to have all of their accounts.

More importantly though, this is really the time for banks (and credit unions) to really evaluate what it means to have a “customer relationship” in the financial services world. Towards the bottom of the list of things that Citibank and JP Morgan Chase should be doing with Wachovia and WaMu customers is “cross-selling” them.

Technorati Tags: Banking, Marketing, American Banker, JP Morgan Chase, Citibank, WaMu

This article was originally published on . All content © 2022 by The Financial Brand and may not be reproduced by any means without permission.