L9 | Web Management for Credit Unions Weber Marketing Group - Brand Solutions Acton Marketing Blog | Financial Marketing Insights Momentum | Building. Branding. Breakthroughs. CU*SWAG | T-Shirts for Credit Unions

Posts tagged ‘robberies’

Freeze! The cold hard facts on bank robberies in 2009

Wednesday, March 31st, 2010

You might think that bank robberies would be on the climb during The Great Recession. But so far, that hasn’t been case. Using official FBI data, The Financial Brand looked at bank robbery statistics for the 47,242 robberies of U.S. financial institutions that occurred between 2003 and 2009. The study showed that even though Americans are reeling from one of the worst economic periods in the country’s history, bank robberies are actually on the decline.

In 2003 there were 7,442 robberies, dropping to 5,943 in 2009. That’s nearly 1,500 fewer robberies.

Every year, there are between 5,000 and 6,000 commercial banks robbed, compared with fewer than 500 credit union robberies. Commercial banks are the most common target, representing 88.8% of all robberies.

2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Total %
Commercial Bank 6,530 6,687 6,019 6,154 5,305 5,960 5,316 41,971 88.8%
Mutual Savings 186 168 129 114 103 110 51 861 1.8%
Savings & Loan 226 188 144 159 127 147 106 1,097 2.3%
Credit Union 500 467 422 521 450 483 470 3,313 7.0%
Total 7,442 7,510 6,714 6,948 5,985 6,700 5,943 47,242 100%

Demand notes are used in 56.7% of robberies. Robbers threaten to have a weapon 45% of the time. When a weapon is used, handguns are the most common. Slightly more than one in four robbers reveal their handgun. A mere 3% threaten to possess a bomb or other explosive device.

Robbers have not gotten much smarter over the years. Despite harsher penalties for using a firearm in the commission of a felony, the same percentage of robbers use guns today as they did seven years ago.

A total of just under $46 million in loot was taken by robbers in 2009. That’s an average haul of only $7,736.50.

Contrary to popular belief, the risk of robbery does not increase significantly on Fridays. A financial institution is no more than 4% more likely to be robbed on a Friday vs. any other weekday. The risk is only three times greater for a robbery on a Friday than on a Saturday. An alarming 7% of robberies occur on Saturdays, which is quite surprising considering the shorter branch hours and fewer number of branches that are open.

More than a quarter of all robberies occur between 9 a.m. and 11 a.m. Branches are at their highest risk of robbery in the first two hours after they open, with the level of risk diminishing slightly as the day progresses. The fewest daytime robberies occur in the last three hours of the day (between 3:00 p.m. and 6:00 p.m.) Only 7% of all robberies occur after hours (between 6 p.m. and 9 a.m.).

2009 was the first year the FBI started tracking takeovers as a method of robbery. In 2009, there were 306 takeovers, representing only 0.6% of all robberies.

The perpetrator of a robbery is predominantly male. In 2009, the ratio of male to female robbers was 16:1. 41% of perpetrators are white, 46% black, 8% Hispanic and 5% from other ethnicities.

2003 2004 2005 2006 2007 2008 2009 Total
Injuries 153 146 141 129 111 123 140 943
Deaths 21 20 21 13 19 21 21 136
Hostages 82 74 70 80 102 105 94 607

Out of over 47,000 robberies in the last 7 years, only 9 employees and customers were killed.

Between 2003 and 2009, a total of 136 people have been killed in the course of financial institution robberies, 108 of them were perpetrators (79%). In those seven years, a total of 28 people other than perpetrators were killed, only 9 of which were employees or customers.

In 2009, all 21/21 of the people killed in the commission of a robbery were perpetrators. It’s quite likely that 2009 was the first year in U.S. history where no one other than perpetrators were killed during a robbery.

Convicted bank robber shares branch security insights

Wednesday, November 4th, 2009

[Note: If The Financial Brand covered another industry, we probably wouldn’t spend so much time talking about security. But robbers rob financial institutions because “that’s where the money is.” Security impacts the consumer's experience more so at financial institutions than just about anywhere else (except the airport). So The Financial Brand figured who else would be better to talk to about branch security than a convicted bank robber. Enjoy!]

When you’re in prison, you’ve got plenty of time to learn some things. For instance, guys convicted for armed robbery quickly learn that it’s much smarter to pass notes at banks than hold up a liquor store at gunpoint. Not only will you face a lighter sentence, you don’t have to worry about someone whipping out a shotgun and shooting back.

troy-evans-closeupThere’s a lot one can learn about robbing banks when in prison. And who better to learn from than Troy Evans?

“You’ll only get 30-36 months if you use a note,” he says.

Back in 1992, Troy Evans was sentenced to 13 years in the Federal Correctional Complex in Florence, Colorado. He was convicted of multiple bank robberies in three states over six months.

How many banks did he rob?

“More than the five I was convicted of,” Evans admits.

Evans biggest haul: $17,000, when he caught a teller in the middle of a count.

Evans only served seven years of his sentence before being released early, but earned two degrees with a 4.0 GPA during his time.

Since his release, Evans has dedicated himself to helping financial institutions minimize their risk of robbery. Capitalizing on his experiences as a bank robber and his reputation as an ex-con, Evans has forged a successful career as a noted speaker and branch security consultant who’s authored two books.

troy-evans-dvdHe has been featured on Good Morning America, CNN, FOX, The Washington Post, Chicago Tribune, Newsday, The New Yorker and more. Evans has even published a DVD/CD training tool for financial institutions, Deterring & Responding to Robberies, (which you can order here through Bankerstuff.com).

It may sound a little like the fox guarding the hen house, but Evans has achieved a truly impressive turnaround — something very similar to Frank Abagnale’s story.

A “hello” from staff can mean “goodbye robber”

For research, Evans met and interviewed some 300 convicted bank robbers, and he’s found a lot of common themes. For instance, what’s the one thing robbers are looking for when casing a branch?

“They are always looking for the path of least resistance,” he says.

Evans would always “case the joint,” as he puts it, before the robbery, sometimes 2-3 weeks in advance.

“I’d come in and ask to exchange a $10 bill for a roll of quarters,” he explains. While conducting the transaction, Evans would note how engaged staff were. Were employees paying attention? Did they say hello? Did someone extend a hand and welcome him?

“The last thing a robber wants is for someone to notice them. Someone to look them in the eyes,” he says.

“If anything makes a robber uncomfortable, they’ll move on to another location,” says Evans. “There’s just too many other financial institutions to choose from to bother with the ones who notice and acknowledge you.”

But did they even notice him? Evans apparently had no trouble finding detached and distant employees working at the dozen or so banks (and one credit union) he claims to have robbed.

“That’s why your frontline people are the most precious resource in robbery prevention,” Evans says. “And the #1 priority is to prevent your financial institution from being selected in the first place.”

Indeed what Evans is referring to are the principles behind Operation Safecatch. If staff say hello and acknowledge people as they enter your branches, not only will they be getting great service, staff will be minimizing the risk or robbery.

“There were a couple dozen banks I really wanted to rob,” Evans admits. “But they made their presence known.”

Keep it confidential

troy-evansEvans says he got the idea to start robbing banks from a girl he was dating. She worked as a teller at a bank, telling him all the ins-and-outs of branch security — bait money, dye packs, policies of compliance, etc.

“I learned that all I had to do was ask,” Evans says. “Employees were told to comply, so if I told them, ‘Don’t give me any bait money,’ they didn’t.”

That’s why Evans recommends financial institutions have all their employees sign non-disclosure agreements.

“They shouldn’t ever discuss anything about security with anyone ever,” Evans cautions.

He recommends you make such a non-disclosure agreement binding beyond employment.

And in case you were wondering, no, Evans never robbed his girlfriend’s bank.

Be alert on Fridays

Evans says robbers believe financial institutions have more money on Fridays for people cashing their paychecks. True or not, it’s the reason he says banks are targeted more frequently on Fridays.

But Evans points out there can be other reasons too. For instance, if the robber has a drug problem (as Evans did), the fear of a weekend without a fix can drive them to find the nerve.

“Usually bank robberies are an act of desperation,” Evans observes. “It’s usually something related to drugs, gambling or debt — maybe foreclosure. They’d rather rob a bank than deal with an ugly weekend.”

Bullet Proof Glass

Evans says he never even considered robbing a branch that had bullet proof (or, more accurately, “bullet resistant”) glass. But, he wonders, “What’s the cost to the financial institution? Aren’t they supposed to be in the ‘people business?’ Isn’t it supposed to be all about ‘building relationships?’ How can you do that behind a two-inch thick glass barrier?”

Suspicious Activities Log

Evans says another way financial institutions can improve branch security is to keep a “Suspicious Activities Log” at each branch. Every teller and every employee is responsible for each other’s safety, so if they’re alert and pay attention, they might notice something that someone else needs to know about on another shift.

“You want employees to know what look for if someone’s been casing the branch,” Evans recommends.

If you do get robbed…

“Stay calm and pay attention,” Evans says. “It’s critical that you notice everything you can about the robber.”

“Look for identifying marks — scars, tattoos,” he recommends. “Pay attention to anything you can use to identify the robber later.”

For instance, Evans points out, “My right ear is larger than my left ear.”

“The more you notice, the better the chances are that the robber gets caught and convicted.”

Immediately following a robbery, Evans strongly urges all employees to sit down and write out every single detail they can recall. He encourages every financial institution to institute this recommendation as policy.

Evans’ Day of Reckoning

One night in 1992, Evans was staying at a hotel in Denver when the hotel’s manager gave him a call.

“This is the front desk,” the man said. “We’re all booked up, so we need you to come down and pay your next night in advance.”

After ignoring the first call, Evans was phoned again with a reminder to come down to the office to pay for his next night.

As Evans walked through the parking lot to the office, he saw a swarm of men armed with automatic weapons. They were coming for him.

How did he get caught? He was ratted out, as the expression goes, by another ex-girlfriend (not the one who was the teller at a bank, a different one). One day after robbing a bank, Evans came home expecting his girlfriend to be at work.

“I walked into the house stuffed with a pile of money, and she wanted to know where it came from,” he says.

He lied about it’s origin, but the girlfriend remained suspicious. Years later when she heard about a bank robbery, details made her recall the mysterious money incident and she immediately suspected Evans. She called the cops, and Evans was nabbed.

“It’s good that they caught me when they did,” Evans confesses. “I was strung out on drugs and in a very dark place. I had been thinking about committing suicide-by-police.”

Fortunately, Evans didn’t have his gun on him at the time of his arrest.

“I never had it loaded anyway,” Evans admits. “It was always just for show.”

Operation Safecatch: A Proactive Approach to Robberies

Monday, August 10th, 2009


SAFECATCH doesn’t put bank employees in danger, but it does empower them to make a potential robber think twice about going through with it,” says Special Agent Larry Carr.

Conventional wisdom in the financial industry regarding how to contend with robberies can be summed up in one word: compliance. Hand over the money and make sure nobody gets hurt. While well intended, the FBI has found this approach may actually be a contributing factor to the number of banks being robbed.

“The expense of integrating SAFECATCH into new BRANCH DESIGN is zero.”
– Paul Seibert, EHS Design

But last week, a teller in Seattle chased a would-be robber from the bank, wrestled him to the ground several blocks later and held him there until police came. To some, the teller’s actions were heroic, while others felt he exposed everyone to a ton of risk.

While police and the FBI discourage behavior like the teller’s admittedly instinctive response, the FBI says there is indeed a proactive way for bank employees to be heroes without jeopardizing anyone’s safety. They call it “Safecatch,” where bank employees are trained to spot suspicious behavior and safely take control of the situation before a robbery occurs.

SAFECATCH doesn’t put bank employees in danger, but it does empower them to make a potential robber think twice about going through with it, and if he does, it teaches employees to partner with law enforcement to safely assist in the capture,” says Special Agent Larry Carr, the FBI’s Seattle bank robbery coordinator who created the SAFECATCH concept several years ago.

Employees trained in SAFECATCH learn to spot “customers” who may be acting nervously or wearing hats or hooded sweatshirts-to shield their faces from security cameras. Before a robbery occurs, employees proactively engage the person.

“Good afternoon!” the employee might say. “I don’t think I’ve seen you in this branch before. If you’re here to open a new account, I can take your ID and help you at my desk.”

That action might be just enough to make the robber head for the door. If the person turns out to be a legitimate customer, Carr said, the only thing the employee has done is offer excellent customer service.

One key piece of the SAFECATCH strategy is making sure branch employees — specifically tellers — can keep an eye on people. “Highly trained relationship staff at transaction pods can view members throughout their entry and exit and have a safe way to exit potentially dangerous situations and call 911,” says Paul Seibert, a principal with EHS Design and one of the financial industry’s foremost architects. Seibert helped the FBI’s Carr develop the SAFECATCH program.

Since 2006, Carr has provided SAFECATCH training to some 40 financial institutions in Washington state — that’s about 400 bank branches and 3,000 employees. Last year, Seattle saw a 51% decrease in the number of bank robberies from its decade average, which is even more impressive considering that in many parts of the country bank robberies are on the rise.

The majority of bank robbers are males acting alone without weapons-they know that using a weapon during a robbery can mean a lot more jail time. The robber typically poses as a customer waiting in line. It’s only when he gets to the teller’s window and makes a demand that he has committed a crime.

“It’s important to catch the guy after his first robbery and before he can strike again,” Carr said. “If we teach strategies that make it possible to safely achieve a police capture, you will see dramatic drop in an area’s bank robbery rate.”

Source: FBI

Instead of saying “hi” to robber, teller gets himself fired

Wednesday, August 5th, 2009

“When the man came into the bank…dressed in a knit cap on one of the hottest days of the year, Nicholson [a bank teller] says he was immediately uneasy. The suspicious-looking man walked in and out of the bank, then got in the teller line, then stepped out of line.”

This excerpt comes from a Seattle Times story about a teller who was fired for foiling an attempted bank robbery.

Here’s what happened. A would-be robber handed a bag to Jim Nicholson, a two-year teller with KeyBank, and demanded it be filled with money. Nicholson “threw the bag to the floor, lunged toward the robber and demanded to see a weapon. Surprised, the would-be bank robber backed up and then bolted.”

Key Questions: Who demands to have someone shove a gun in their face? Doesn’t Nicholson have a mother/brother/wife/child? And what would have happened if the robber — already irritated by a non-compliant employee — had been forced to brandish his weapon?

Then Nicholson pursued the man for several blocks before knocking him to the ground, holding him until police arrived.

Reality Check: Brave, but foolish.

KeyBank fired Nicholson shortly after.

This situation illustrates a series of intertwined points about service, security and training.

First, when a suspicious person enters your branch, you don’t sit back and wait for them to rob you. In KeyBank’s case, Nicholson had ample cues and more than enough time to intercept the robber before things escalated. What was he waiting for? Instead, Nicholson should have stopped whatever he was doing, walked up to the person, shook his hand and said, “Hello! Welcome to KeyBank. Are you here to open an account, or is there anything else I can help you with today?” As The Financial Brand has previously noted (here, and again here), this completely throws a would-be robber off his M.O.: “Crap! I’ve been noticed. They’re on to me.”

“If a person is a legitimate customer, they will experience superior service,” says FBI Special Agent Larry Carr. “If their intention, however, is to rob the bank, they will experience paranoia, anxiety and a desire to escape.”

Robbers expect to encounter the same level of predictably-indifferent, emotionally-detached service from one financial institution to the next. In fact, they are counting on employees to do exactly what most have been trained to do — acquiesce. But when the situation presents developments that the robber didn’t anticipate, he/she simply doesn’t know how to respond. In fact, it confuses some robbers so much that employees have actually been able to get the potential robber to open an account.

This isn’t a perfect security system; there isn’t such a thing. But for all the security measures financial institutions put in place to mitigate the severity of robberies — cameras, bullet-resistant glass, man traps, dye packs, etc. — it’s completely baffling why more don’t teach this basic robbery prevention technique (PDF).

Have you ever heard of any other security measure that’s so effective it can thwart the same robber twice in one day at two separate banks? What other security measures can you think of that actually stops robberies before they take place?

Bottom Line: The KeyBank brand is suffering a public lynching. The story at The Seattle Times has received over 650 comments, and almost all of them rip into KeyBank harshly. It seems the vigilante in folks — our inner Rambo — wants to root for Nicholson and condemn KeyBank, even though KeyBank’s policy is as straightforward as it is common: they expect staff to comply with robbers’ demands inasmuch as it avoids violent confrontations. In this situation, confrontation wasn’t necessary; it was completely avoidable. For risking the lives of his co-workers, his customers, himself and innocent bystanders on the street, KeyBank was probably right to fire Nicholson. Having service mavericks — like Southwest Airlines does — is one thing, but having security mavericks is another. When it comes to people’s safety, you can’t have employees picking and choosing which rules they should follow.

Key Takeaway: Saying “hi” to suspicious people = security + service. This applies equally to shoplifters and department stores as it does armed gunmen and banks.

KeyBank should teach its tellers what could be done differently — besides just meekly complying with the robber after the robbery is initiated. Unfortunately, the message most KeyBank employees will likely get is “do what you’re told” when given instructions by KeyBank Corporate…or by a robber. If you don’t, you’re fired.

Should Nicholson have been fired?

View Results

Loading ... Loading ...

2 banks use great service to thwart 1 robber

Tuesday, November 11th, 2008


The would-be thief in this FBI image is a suspect in several bank robberies.

The employees working in a Seattle branch of First Mutual Bank recognized the man immediately. They’d seen his photo on a flier from the FBI and knew he was a suspect in previous bank robberies.

Instead of waiting for the man to rob them, the bank’s employees snapped to action. But they didn’t trigger any alarms, or call the police and run to the vault hugging each other.

“If a person is a legitimate customer, they will experience superior service. If their intention, however, is to rob the bank, they will experience paranoia, anxiety and a desire to escape.”
FBI Special Agent Larry Carr

They just started a conversation with the man by greeting him and saying hello.

The man left the branch without any money — and without incident.

You might think this is a silly way to thwart a would-be robber, but it works.

Twice in a row, as a matter of fact.

After the robber left First Mutual, a bank employee called a nearby U.S. Bank to give them a heads-up: the man might be coming their way next.

Sure enough, the guy walked into the U.S. Bank branch, but to his dismay, he confronted the same sort of friendly, personal service he found at the First Mutual location. So he left, empty-handed again.

Key Insight: Robbers don’t like good customer service. A personal touch coupled with questions about opening a checking account annoys robbers. Why? Because they would prefer to remain fully anonymous and unseen. And because good service doesn’t fit the BRANCH EXPERIENCE they usually encounter. In a sense, good, personal service is so uncommon that it surprises robbers, catching them off guard.

As FBI Special Agent Larry Carr puts it, “If a person is a legitimate customer, they will experience superior service. If their intention, however, is to rob the bank, they will experience paranoia, anxiety and a desire to escape.”

Carr worked with EHS Design, the financial industry’s leading architectural firm, to develop a complete strategy for secure BRANCH DESIGN, something they call SAFECATCH. NPR even did a piece about it last year.

Robbers will often “case the joint” before robbing it. If they walk in and are confronted with attentive staff who seem to be “on their game,” they’ll move on to softer targets. Remember: They’re after easy money.

Reality Check: You should be providing great service to everyone who walks through your branch door…no matter what — people with purple mohawks, 14-year olds, even guys with sunglasses and hoodies. If not because you want more business, then at least for the safety of your employees.

Bottom Line: Banks, 2. Robber, 0.

You don’t need to turn your branches into medieval fortresses to prevent robberies. A branch built like Fort Knox undermines your ability to ability to provide warm, friendly personal service.

Who knows, a greeter might be a more effective method of preventing robberies than having an armed security guard. One thing is for certain: greeting people with a friendly handshake, a genuine smile and a warm hello definitely helps create a positive brand image — especially among your law-abiding branch customers.

If you want more information about SAFECATCH, check out this brochure (PDF) or contact EHS Design.

Robbery statistics for Q1 2008

Tuesday, October 28th, 2008

Here’s the FBI’s latest data on robberies of financial institutions for the first three months of 2008.

Type of
Institution
Robberies %
Commercial bank 1,399 87.2%
Mutual savings bank 32 1.9%
Savings and loan 41 2.6%
Credit union 132 8.2%
TOTAL 1,604 100%

Mode of Robbery #
Demand note used 947
Firearm used 405
Handgun 381
Other firearm 26
Other weapon used 25
Weapon threatened 702
Explosive device used or threatened 52
Oral demand 875
Vault or safe theft 18
Deposit trap 3
Till theft 24

Type of Area Robberies %
Metropolitan 809 49.3%
Suburban 250 15.2%
Small city or town 545 33.2%
Rural 37 2.3%

Alarm Systems

Alarm systems were installed and maintained in 96.2% of all institutions robbed. Of those, they were activated 92.7% of the time, meaning that in 61 robberies the alarm wasn’t activated. Thirteen times an alarm was activated but it didn’t work.

Key Question: In this day and age, how can any bank or credit union not have an alarm system (that works)?

Surveillance Cameras

Cameras were installed in all but 23 institutions that were robbed. In 44 instances, cameras were installed but not activated. Seven times cameras were installed but failed to capture the crime.

Loot Taken: $16 million

Loot Recovered: $2.3 million

Key Takeaways:

  • The presence of anti-robbery measures only reduces robberies — it does not prevent them.
  • Anti-robbery systems do not work all the time.
  • Expect robberies to increase sharply as the economy worsens.

Freeze! The cold hard facts on robberies 2006

Thursday, July 3rd, 2008

Here is the FBI’s official data on robberies of financial institutions, including injuries and deaths for 2006.

TOTAL NUMBER OF ROBBERIES: 6,985

  • Bank robberies: 6,154 (88%)
  • Credit union robberies: 521 (7%)
  • Other (e.g., check cashing): 372 (5%)

INJURIES:

  • Number of incidents in which injuries occurred: 94 (1.3%)
  • Customer: 17
  • Employee: 75
  • Employee Family: 0
  • Perpetrator: 17
  • Law Officer: 8
  • Guard: 5
  • Other: 7

DEATHS:

  • Number of incidents in which deaths occurred: 13 (0.2%)
  • Customer: 0
  • Employee: 1
  • Employee Family: 0
  • Perpetrator: 10
  • Law Officer: 1
  • Guard: 1
  • Other: 0

Credit unions aren’t robbers favorite targets. Small branches with no or small vaults lack the significant stockpiles of cash that tantalize robbers. Also, many CU branches are off the beaten path, and robbers prefer easy access to main roads, thoroughfares and freeways – the quick, easy getaway.

CUs can probably also thank their image for fewer robberies. Robbers may not see CUs as big, lucrative “scores” for the same reasons many people struggle to see CUs as full-service financial providers.

Unfortunately, the FBI either does not publish or doesn’t have data comparing robberies and injuries/deaths vs. various security measures vs. branch size/designs vs. cash handling systems.

As a financial institution responsible for your staff’s safety, it likely that your fears of employee injury and death exceed the reality. Only 1.5% of all robberies result in the injury or death of an employee – and that’s assuming you get robbed in the first place. Applying this ratio to CU robberies means that only five credit union employees are injured every year across the country from robberies. And only one credit union employee is killed every five years in the course of a robbery.

Statistically speaking, working in a CU is probably safer than working in a bar, night club or gas station. And it has to be a lot safer than working in construction jobs.

Reality Check #1: Just because you are in a cash-intensive business doesn’t mean you need to build your branches like fortresses.

When you wall your employees off behind bullet-proof glass, you’re erecting a barrier between you and the people you serve – physically, visually and aurally. This is a literal roadblock to building relationships.

Reality Check #2: You can’t have bullet-proof “bandit barriers” if you’re going to say you’re “all about warm, friendly, personal service.”

Do people really feel comfortable discussing sensitive financial subjects through a four-inch hole in an inch-thick sheet of acrylic?

Employee safety wouldn’t be an issue if your branches didn’t get robbed. Bullet-proof glass is a treatment for a symptom, not the root problem, and there are other things you can do to deter robbers.

For starters, you can move your teller lines as far away from the entrance as possible, and cutoff sightlines between the transaction zone and any exits. Robbers get uneasy with each step they take further into a branch, and they get really uncomfortable when they can’t see an exit at the height of the robbery.

Simply saying “hi” to a robber when he comes in to scope the branch is often enough to scare him off (hint: “greeters”).

Reality Check #3: Your average architect doesn’t know how to design “robbery-resistant branches.” Most local architects will design branches that look just like everyone else’s…because “that’s what branches are supposed to look like, right?”

Bottom Line:

  • Building branches like Fort Knox makes you look just like everyone else.
  • You can reduce your risk of robbery with careful BRANCH DESIGN and how you manage your in-BRANCH EXPERIENCE.
  • A well-engineered branch not only mitigates risk of robbery, it also builds your brand and helps cultivate relationships